How Do SEO Consultants Measure Success and ROI?

• Overview
• What I Think
• Deep Dive: Measuring SEO Success
• 10-Step Action Plan for Measuring SEO Success with Your SEO Vendor
• Quick Solutions
• About Us

Overview

SEO consultants and agencies use a wide range of metrics to measure ROI, but every agency is different. However, if you analyze a certain set of data, you can get a better understanding of SEO performance. 

What I Think

Determining the effectiveness of SEO efforts can be challenging due to the multifaceted nature of digital marketing metrics. 

It’s true that many businesses struggle to connect their SEO investments to measurable outcomes such as revenue. 

But, in my experience, a structured approach to performance tracking helps bridge this gap effectively.

Metrics such as keyword efficacy leading to visibility in the search results, organic traffic and targeted leads provide a clear picture of SEO efficacy. 

However, these metrics must be analyzed in context to understand their true impact on a business’s bottom line. 

For example, integrating customer insights and transaction data can help you better understand SEO-driven growth.

Then, being able to evaluate ROI through defined benchmarks and periodic reviews is key to optimizing SEO strategies. 

This, of course, requires collaboration between consultants and clients to align on expectations and goals. 

Deep Dive: Measuring SEO Success 

Different SEO agencies and consultants track SEO performance in varying ways. Here are some general ways they monitor SEO ROI, and how you can be an active part of it.

Set Goals with Your SEO Agency or Consultant

Measuring SEO success starts by establishing clear objectives at the outset with your SEO vendor.

Goals can be anything from increasing organic traffic, improving domain authority, enhancing user engagement or driving revenue. 

These objectives should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound (SMART) to guide SEO efforts. 

Setting these benchmarks helps align SEO strategies to desired outcomes.

Understand How Analytics Come into Play

Analytics play a pivotal role in tracking KPIs. Ask about the analytics platforms your SEO vendor uses — and share yours with them.

Platforms like Google Analytics and Google Search Console offer specialized SEO insights into traffic sources, user behavior and conversion rates. 

But agencies usually have access to other SEO tools as well that offer unique insights into your programs. 

Track Keyword Performance with Your Agency or Consultant

Keyword performance can be an indicator of strategy success. 

When you track the visibility and rankings of target keywords over time, you can track the effectiveness of content and optimization efforts. 

Plus, identifying new keywords helps capture untapped audience segments. So regular updates to keyword strategies ensures alignment with changing search behaviors and industry trends.

Track User Engagement

User engagement metrics on the site give insights into the quality of the user experience. These metrics indicate how well the website meets visitors’ needs and expectations. 

Enhancing user experience not only supports SEO but also creates customer satisfaction and loyalty. Continuous improvements in this area are the key for sustained SEO success.

Understand Your Backlink Profile 

Backlink profiles are yet another way to measure SEO success. 

The quality (not necessarily the quantity) of backlinks can indicate a site’s authority and trustworthiness. High-quality backlinks can significantly contribute to visibility and traffic to a site, among other KPIs.

Access Key Reports

SEO vendors use reporting and communication strategies to help ensure that clients have transparency and for accountability.  

This should include regular sharing of performance updates with reports that are tailored to different stakeholders, and include visual aids such as graphs and charts to clarify complex data. 

This ongoing dialogue between the consultants, agencies and clients helps strengthen the partnership.

Know What SEO Can and Can’t Do

While SEO’s goal is to drive visibility in the search results and traffic to your site, tracking conversion metrics can provide an alternate view of ROI.

Keep in mind that SEO vendors are typically qualified to advise on how to improve your website for conversions, but they cannot guarantee that traffic will convert if clients do not take their advice or follow the guidance of conversion optimization specialists. 

In the same vein, SEOs are not responsible for internal sales workflows, which may impact the effectiveness of an SEO program to convert qualified leads. 

Nevertheless, evaluating metrics such as lead generation, engagement rates and sales/revenue can show the impact of SEO on revenue growth. 

In addition, consultants often use attribution models to understand the contribution of SEO to the customer journey. These insights inform adjustments that enhance overall performance.

10-Step Action Plan for Measuring SEO Success with Your SEO Vendor

Here are some general ways that you can be sure to track SEO ROI with your SEO agency or consultant:

1. Define clear and specific objectives for the SEO strategy with the SEO vendor, and align SEO goals with broader business objectives.
2. Use SMART benchmarks to measure success.
3. Understand what analytics tools they use, and give them access to your data. Select any new appropriate analytics tools as needed. Update keyword strategies to reflect current trends.
4. Track the visibility and rankings of target keywords in the search results, and monitor organic traffic over time.
5. Evaluate the quality of backlinks.
6. Analyze user engagement metrics, and assess conversion rates for specific landing pages.
7. Use attribution models to link SEO efforts to business outcomes.
8. Gain access to reports to communicate performance insights to stakeholders. Be sure they use visual tools to clarify complex data and trends.
9. Gain access to education from your SEO vendor on how to interpret SEO metrics as needed.
10. Schedule periodic reviews to evaluate strategy effectiveness, and to ensure alignment with evolving business goals.

Discover how expert SEO insights can drive measurable success for your business:

Contact Us to Align Your SEO Strategies with Your Business Goals!

Quick Solutions

• How Do I Uncover SEO Opportunities My Team Might Have Missed?
• How Do I Create an SEO Strategy That Adapts to My Business’s Unique Goals and Market Changes?
• How Do I Gain Access to Expert-Level SEO Support When I Need It Most?
• How Do I Integrate External SEO Expertise With My In-House Team Effectively?

About Us

Bruce Clay Inc. has been a leader in SEO innovation since 1996. Our team specializes in ethical and effective SEO practices that align with business goals. With a commitment to transparency and collaboration, we empower organizations to achieve sustained SEO success. Learn more About Us.

Bruce Clay is founder and president of Bruce Clay Inc., a global digital marketing firm providing search engine optimization, pay-per-click, social media marketing, SEO-friendly web architecture, and SEO tools and education. Connect with him on LinkedIn or through the BruceClay.com website.

See Bruce's author page for links to connect on social media.